Saturday, September 5, 2015

Picture Book Review #1 - "A Ball for Daisy"



"A Ball for Daisy" by Chris Raschka



1.     BIBLIOGRAPHY

Raschka, Chris. A Ball for Daisy. New York: Schwartz & Wade Books, 2011.      ISBN 978-0-375-85851-1 

2.     PLOT SUMMARY

A Ball for Daisy is a wordless picture book that tells the story of a dog named Daisy and her favorite ball. Daisy loves the ball so much that she takes it everywhere with her and even sleeps with it. Her owner takes Daisy out for a walk one day and her ball gets taken away by another dog wanting to play. Daisy tries her hardest to get her ball back but the other dog is having too much fun playing with it. Unfortunately, while the other dog was playing with the ball he pops it by accident. Daisy is very sad that she lost her ball. Her owner throws the ball in the trash and takes Daisy home. Daisy's owner takes her for another walk and they see the same dog with a new blue ball. The other dog gives the new blue ball to Daisy which makes her very happy.

3.      CRITICAL ANALYSIS

Daisy is a lovable black, brown, and white dog with floppy ears who loves her red ball. This story is an genuine representation of how a dog behaves when they have a favorite toy. Raschka's illustrations do a great job in showing how much Daisy loves this red ball. You can see and feel all the emotions that Daisy is feeling as she loses the ball to another dog and watches it pop at the park. You can feel her sadness as Daisy walks back home without the ball. When Daisy gets a new blue ball to play with at the park you cannot help but smile and feel happy for her. 

The illustrations are the best part of this book. The illustrations are made with water colors which set this book apart from others. Raschka's pictures take you through the story in a way that words cannot. I loved how some of his illustrations took over both pages and made you go back and forth multiple times before turning the page. This would be a great book to share with kids of all ages.

4.  REVIEW EXCERPT(S)

Caldecott Medal – 2011
New York Times Best Illustrated Children’s Book – 2011
School Library Journal Best Picture Book – 2011
ALA Notable Children’s Books, Younger Readers Category – 2012

From School Library Journal: “Raschka's genius lies in capturing the essence of situations that are deeply felt by children.”

From Publisher’s Weekly: “Readers should relate to Daisy’s sadness over the loss of her treasured object while understanding that such losses can sometimes lead to unexpected gains-maybe even a friend.”

5.      CONNECTIONS
Gather other wordless Caldecott Medal books to read such as:
Macaulay, David, Black and White, ISBN: 978-0-618-63687-7
Wiesner David, Tuesday, ISBN: 978-0-395-87082-2

Gather other Chris Raschka books to read such as:

Daisy gets lost,  ISBN:  978-0-449-81741-4
Everyone Can Learn to Ride a Bicycle, ISBN:  978-0-375-87007-1

To assist in language development, have students retell the story in their own words as you page through the book.

Read the following books and compare and contrast them to A Ball for Daisy:

Day, Alexandra, Good Dog Carl, ISBN:  978-0-689-80748-0
Camesi, Monica, Little Dog Lost, ISBN:  978-0-399-25666-0
Sullivan, Mary, Ball, ISBN: 978-0-544-31361-3

No comments:

Post a Comment